A pumpkin custard pie in a plain glazed pie plate, its smooth orange-brown filling crossed by a lattice of golden, flaky pastry strips, one slice cut and lifted out to show the set custard.
Pumpkin and cream pie under a lattice of pastry strips, one slice cut.

Pompkin Pudding (1796)

Amelia Simmons’s rich pumpkin pudding of 1796: stewed pumpkin with cream, eggs, sugar, mace, nutmeg and ginger, baked in a butter and lard paste under a crisscross of pastry strips.

Recipe makes
One 9-inch pie, 8 servings
Prep
Cook
Total

The total includes about 50 minutes of chilling the paste between rollings and 2 hours of cooling before slicing. The pumpkin can be stewed and the paste made a day ahead.

Pumpkin and cream pie under a lattice of pastry strips, one slice cut.

The story behind the recipe

Amelia Simmons filed her richer pumpkin pie among the puddings and baked it in pastry, as she did the orange pudding printed just below it, which goes into “rich puff-paste.” Her American Cookery, printed in Hartford that year, gives two under the heading “Pompkin.” This is the first of them, stewed and strained pumpkin with cream, nine eggs, sugar, mace, nutmeg and ginger, laid into one of her two named pastes and crossed with strips of dough.

The dough spur

The strips are cut with a dough spur, a small wheel with a fluted edge on a handle, which leaves a crimped line as it rolls. Simmons reaches for it again a few lines on, where her lemon pudding is finished with pieces of paste “cut with a jagging iron or a dough-spur to your fancy,” baked on floured paper and laid on top. Her paste for this pie, No. 7, “A Paste for Sweet Meats,” is richer than most modern crusts: a pound of lard and a third of a pound of butter to two pounds of flour, wet with beaten egg whites, with the rest of the shortening rolled in over ten or twelve rollings. It ends with two words of oven advice: “bake quick.”

The second version is plainer, with milk, fewer eggs, molasses and allspice. The printed corrections bound into the book allow milk wherever her puddings call for cream. How these two pies sit between Josselyn’s stewed pumpkin and Lydia Maria Child’s family pie is told in What Did Americans Do with Pumpkin Before Pumpkin Pie?

Read more about this recipe

Making it today

The biggest change is size. Simmons’s quart of pumpkin and three pints of cream would fill about four modern pie plates, so this is a quarter batch, with two eggs where her proportions give two and a quarter. She gives no amount of sugar or spice; the half cup of sugar and the spice measures are ours, and light cream stands in for a cream whose richness she doesn’t state. Her paste keeps its lard and her egg whites, cut down to one. The oven starts hot, in the spirit of “bake quick,” then drops so the custard sets gently. For the plainer, milk-and-molasses side of the story, bake the Pumpkin Pie (1832) beside it.

Pompkin.

No. 1. One quart stewed and strained, 3 pints cream, 9 beaten eggs, sugar, mace, nutmeg and ginger, laid into paste No. 7 or 3, and with a dough spur, cross and chequer it, and baked in dishes three quarters of an hour.

No. 2. One quart of milk, 1 pint pompkin, 4 eggs, molasses, allspice and ginger in a crust, bake 1 hour.

A Paste for Sweet Meats.

No. 7. Rub one third of one pound of butter, and one pound of lard into two pound of flour, wet with four whites well beaten; water q: s: to make a paste, roll in the residue of shortning in ten or twelve rollings—bake quick.

Amelia SimmonsAmerican Cookery (Hartford: Hudson & Goodwin, for the author, 1796), pp. 28–29

Read the full story

Ingredients

For One 9-inch pie, 8 servings. Quantities are shown as written.

Quantities as written here, for One 9-inch pie, 8 servings.

Paste

  • All-purpose flour1 3/4 cups
  • All-purpose flour, for rolling2 tbsp
  • Cold lard1/2 cup
  • Cold unsalted butter, for rubbing in3 tbsp
  • Cold unsalted butter, for rolling in5 tbsp
  • Large egg white, beaten1
  • Ice water4 tbsp

Filling

  • Stewed and strained pumpkin1 cup
  • Large eggs2
  • Sugar1/2 cup
  • Ground mace1/4 tsp
  • Freshly grated nutmeg1/4 tsp
  • Ground ginger1/2 tsp
  • Light cream1 1/2 cups
Ingredients as written here
  • 1¾ cups all-purpose flour
  • 2 tbsp all-purpose flour, for rolling
  • ½ cup cold lard
  • 3 tbsp cold unsalted butter, for rubbing in
  • 5 tbsp cold unsalted butter, for rolling in
  • 1 large egg white, beaten
  • 4 tbsp ice water
  • 1 cup stewed and strained pumpkin
  • 2 large eggs
  • ½ cup sugar
  • ¼ tsp ground mace
  • ¼ tsp freshly grated nutmeg
  • ½ tsp ground ginger
  • 1½ cups light cream
Equipment
  • Knife and board
  • Saucepan with a lid
  • Sieve
  • Bowl
  • Fork
  • Rolling pin
  • Plastic wrap
  • 9-inch pie plate
  • Sharp knife
  • Whisk
  • Small baking dish
  • Rimmed baking sheet
  • Aluminum foil
  • Instant-read thermometer
  • Wire rack

Instructions

  1. For the stewed and strained pumpkin, peel and seed a small pie pumpkin and cut it into chunks. Put them in the saucepan with a splash of water, cover and simmer gently until very soft, about 20 minutes. Drain well, press through the sieve and let cool. Measure what the list calls for and keep any extra for another use.

  2. For the paste, put the all-purpose flour in the bowl. Rub in the lard and the butter for rubbing in with your fingertips until the mixture looks like coarse crumbs.

  3. Stir the egg white into the ice water, sprinkle it over the crumbs and mix with the fork until the paste holds together when pressed. If it stays dry, add a few drops more water.

  4. Dust the board with some of the flour for rolling and roll the paste into a rectangle about ¼ inch thick. Dot a third of the butter for rolling in over two-thirds of it, fold it in three, and roll it out again. Repeat with the second third and then the last.

  5. Roll and fold the paste a few more times without butter. Whenever the butter softens and starts to stick, wrap the paste in plastic wrap and chill it for 20 minutes. When all the butter is in and the paste is smooth, wrap it and chill it for 30 minutes.

  6. Heat the oven to 425°F (220°C) with a shelf in the lower third. Cut off about a fifth of the paste and set it aside. Roll the rest about ⅛ inch thick, line the pie plate, trim the edge and chill it while you make the filling.

  7. Roll out the reserved paste and cut it into strips about ½ inch wide with the sharp knife.

  8. Whisk the eggs in the bowl, then whisk in the sugar, mace, nutmeg and ginger. Whisk in the pumpkin, then the light cream, without beating in much air.

  9. Set the lined pie plate on the baking sheet. Pour in the filling until it is ¼ inch below the rim of the paste, and pour any left over into the small baking dish. Lay the strips across the pie in a crisscross and press their ends onto the rim.

  10. Bake for 15 minutes, then turn the oven down to 350°F (175°C) and bake for 35 to 45 minutes more, until the edge is set, the center wobbles only slightly when you nudge the plate, and an instant-read thermometer in the center reads 160°F (71°C). If the rim browns too fast, cover it with strips of foil. Bake the small dish of extra filling on the same sheet and take it out when its center reads 160°F (71°C), from about 25 minutes.

  11. Cool the pie on the wire rack for 2 hours before slicing. Serve it at room temperature or cold, and refrigerate it within 2 hours of baking.

Nutrition

490calories per serving

Recipe makes
One 9-inch pie, 8 servings
Servings
8

Estimated per serving (8) from USDA FoodData Central values for flour, lard, butter, light cream, eggs, sugar and pumpkin.

Recipe notes

When adjusting quantities

This is a quarter of Simmons’s batch, sized for one 9-inch pie plate. Her full quantities fill about four such pies.

Notes

Quantities mentioned in these notes don’t change when you adjust the servings.

A pie pumpkin of about 1½ lb gives enough stewed and strained pumpkin, with some to spare. Our changes from Simmons: a quarter batch, two eggs, light cream, set amounts of sugar, mace, nutmeg and ginger, one egg white in the paste, fewer rollings than her ten or twelve, a knife for her dough spur (a fluted pastry wheel gives her crimped edge), a 9-inch pie plate, a hot start at 425°F (220°C) and a finish at 350°F (175°C) with a thermometer check, and a small dish for any filling that won’t fit. Her other paste, No. 3, is butter alone at three-quarters the weight of the flour, with eggs that her corrections reduce and limit to whites. Her printed errata allow milk wherever a pudding calls for cream. Keep the pie covered in the refrigerator and eat it within 3 to 4 days. Contains gluten, milk and eggs.

Recipe details

Course
Dessert
Dish family
Desserts & Sweets
Region
American
Era
18th century
Event
New England pumpkin, 1672–1832
Main ingredient
VegetablesMilk & cream
Difficulty
Intermediate
Occasion
Thanksgiving
Season
Autumn
Open in a new tab