Round, tall, pale golden biscuits spaced apart on a dark baking sheet, one broken open in front to show a soft white crumb, beside a small dish of butter.
Baking powder biscuits on a baking sheet, one broken open, with butter.

Fannie Farmer’s Baking Powder Biscuit II (1896)

Fannie Farmer’s second baking powder biscuit of 1896, the all-butter, all-milk one: mixed with a knife, rolled half an inch thick and baked fast in a hot oven.

Recipe makes
About 12 biscuits, 2 inches across
Prep
Cook
Total

Heat the oven before you mix: once the milk is in, the dough is cut and baked straight away. Farmer bakes them twelve to fifteen minutes in a hot oven.

Baking powder biscuits on a baking sheet, one broken open, with butter.

The story behind the recipe

Baking Powder Biscuit II is Fannie Farmer’s richer biscuit. It has the same two cups of flour and four teaspoons of baking powder as her first, but two tablespoons of butter where Biscuit I splits the fat between butter and lard, all milk where Biscuit I uses milk and water, and half the salt. She printed it at the top of page 71 of The Boston Cooking-School Cook Book (1896) with a single line of method: “Mix and bake as Baking Powder Biscuit I.” It follows the home-made powder here as the thing the powder was bought for.

What else did Farmer make from it?

A pinwheel. Lower on the same page, her Fruit Rolls (Pin Wheel Biscuit) begin “Mix as Baking Powder Biscuit II,” then roll the dough a quarter of an inch thin, brush it with melted butter, scatter it with chopped raisins, citron, sugar and cinnamon, roll it up like a jelly roll and slice it before baking. Her Emergency Biscuit, between the two, takes Biscuit I or II with more milk, stirred soft enough to drop from a spoon. The butter-and-milk dough was her base for the fancier things, and it carries her rule from page 56 of two teaspoons of baking powder to each cup of flour. Farmer’s book came out in Boston three years before Missouri’s alum act and has no link to the case; it shows what a Boston cooking-school teacher told cooks to expect from the can.

Read more about this recipe

Making it today

We call for a baking powder whose label lists no aluminum compound, or the Home-Made Baking Powder (1918) used measure for measure, so nothing in these biscuits would have fallen under Missouri’s 1899 act. That choice serves the story and makes no health claim. Farmer prints no temperature, so reading her “hot oven” as 425°F (220°C) is our choice, as are the 2-inch cutter, unsalted butter and whole milk; her twelve to fifteen minutes stay. These are not the army’s Baking-Powder Biscuits (1896), a lean dough of lard or dripping rolled thick and baked crowded together; Farmer’s are buttery, half an inch thick and baked apart. What Happened When Missouri Outlawed Alum Baking Powder? tells how a can of powder brought a St. Louis grocer to court.

A printed cookbook page with Baking Powder Biscuit II: 2 cups flour, 4 teaspoons baking powder, half a teaspoon salt, 2 tablespoons butter, three-quarters of a cup of milk, mix and bake as Baking Powder Biscuit I; and below it Emergency Biscuit, made with more milk and dropped from a spoon
Fannie Merritt Farmer, The Boston Cooking-School Cook Book (Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1896), p. 71.

Baking Powder Biscuit II.

2 cups flour. 4 teaspoons baking powder. ½ teaspoon salt. 2 tablespoons butter. ¾ cup milk.

Mix and bake as Baking Powder Biscuit I.

Baking Powder Biscuit I. ...

Mix dry ingredients, and sift twice.

Work in butter and lard with tips of fingers; add gradually the liquid, mixing with knife to a soft dough. It is impossible to determine the exact amount of liquid, owing to differences in flour. Toss on a floured board, pat, and roll lightly to one-half inch in thickness. Shape with a biscuit-cutter. Place on buttered pan, and bake in hot oven twelve to fifteen minutes. If baked in too slow an oven, the gas will escape before it has done its work.

Fannie Merritt FarmerThe Boston Cooking-School Cook Book (Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1896), Baking Powder Biscuit I, p. 70, and Baking Powder Biscuit II, p. 71

Read the full story

Ingredients

For about 12 biscuits, 2 inches across. Quantities are shown as written.

Quantities as written here, for about 12 biscuits, 2 inches across.

  • All-purpose flour, plus more for the board2 cups
  • Aluminum-free baking powder4 tsp
  • Salt1/2 tsp
  • Cold unsalted butter2 tbsp
  • Cold whole milk3/4 cup
  • Soft butter, for greasing
Ingredients as written here
  • 2 cups all-purpose flour, plus more for the board
  • 4 tsp aluminum-free baking powder
  • ½ tsp salt
  • 2 tbsp cold unsalted butter
  • ¾ cup cold whole milk
  • Soft butter, for greasing
Equipment
  • Sieve
  • Mixing bowl
  • Table knife
  • Rolling pin
  • 2-inch biscuit cutter
  • Baking sheet
  • Instant-read thermometer

Instructions

  1. Heat the oven to 425°F (220°C) and grease the baking sheet with soft butter.

  2. Mix the all-purpose flour, aluminum-free baking powder and salt, and sift them together twice into the mixing bowl.

  3. Cut the cold unsalted butter into small pieces and work it into the flour with your fingertips until no piece is bigger than a small pea.

  4. Add the cold whole milk gradually, mixing with the table knife, until the dough is soft and just holds together. Flours differ, so you may not need all of it, or may need a little more.

  5. Turn the dough onto a floured board, toss it lightly to coat, pat it flat and roll it lightly to ½ inch thick.

  6. Cut out rounds with the floured cutter, pressing straight down. Press the scraps together once, pat them out and cut again.

  7. Set the biscuits on the buttered sheet a little apart and bake at once for 12 to 15 minutes, until risen and golden and the center of a middle biscuit reads about 200°F (93°C).

  8. Serve hot.

Nutrition

105calories per serving

Recipe makes
About 12 biscuits, 2 inches across
Servings
12

Estimated per biscuit (12) from USDA FoodData Central values for all-purpose flour, unsalted butter and whole milk; butter for the pan not included.

Recipe notes

When adjusting quantities

Farmer’s own batch: 4 teaspoons of baking powder to 2 cups of flour, her rule of 2 teaspoons to each cup. Scale the flour, powder, salt, butter and milk together.

Notes

Quantities mentioned in these notes don’t change when you adjust the servings.

The amounts are Farmer’s for Biscuit II and the method is her Biscuit I’s, which she tells the cook to follow. The oven setting, the 2-inch cutter, unsalted butter, whole milk and the internal temperature are our choices; at ½ inch thick the batch gives about 12 biscuits. For her Emergency Biscuit, add more milk until the dough drops from a spoon without spreading, drop spoonfuls half an inch apart on a buttered pan, brush with milk and bake 8 minutes in the same hot oven. With the home-made powder, get the biscuits into the oven the moment they are cut. Don’t taste the raw dough: uncooked flour can carry bacteria. The biscuits are best the day they are baked.

Recipe details

Course
Bread & baking
Dish family
Breads & Cakes
Region
American
Era
19th century
Source decade
1890s
Event
Missouri baking powder case, 1903
Main ingredient
Milk & cream
Difficulty
Easy
Occasion
Everyday meal
Open in a new tab