An oval white baking dish of sliced potatoes baked in milk, the top layer browned in patches at the edges, with one serving spooned out to show the soft layers.
Potatoes baked in layers with milk and butter, one serving lifted out.

Escalloped Potatoes (1896)

Fannie Farmer’s escalloped potatoes of 1896: thin slices layered in a buttered dish with salt, pepper, flour and butter, covered with hot milk and baked until soft.

Recipe makes
4 servings
Prep
Cook
Total

About 25 minutes to peel, soak and layer, then about 1¼ hours in a 350°F (175°C) oven, Farmer’s own baking time.

Potatoes baked in layers with milk and butter, one serving lifted out.

The story behind the recipe

Escalloped Potatoes, in Fannie Merritt Farmer’s 1896 Boston Cooking-School Cook Book, are sliced potatoes, flour, butter and hot milk, baked until soft. There is no cheese and no cream. On one of her printed dinner menus they come to the table as “Scalloped Potatoes,” beside braised beef with horseradish sauce.

Raw slices and an hour and a quarter

Farmer spells the dish two ways: “Escalloped” over the recipe on page 278, “Scalloped” on the menu on page 518. Her baking time table on page 34 treats scalloped dishes as quick work, because most of them were made from food already cooked. These potatoes go into the dish raw, which is why the recipe asks for patience, and why the flour on each layer has time to thicken the milk.

Her menu is a Boston dinner of the 1890s with nothing Egyptian about it. It is paired here with meat that went into a tomb at Thebes dried, wrapped and boxed, more than three thousand years earlier, a story told in Why Were Egyptian Meat Offerings Wrapped Like Mummies?.

Read more about this recipe

Making it today

Farmer gives the potatoes, the butter and the baking time, and leaves the oven, the dish and the seasoning to the cook. A 350°F (175°C) oven and a 1½-quart dish are our choices, as are the amounts of salt, pepper, flour and milk. She says only “soak”; fifteen minutes in cold water is ours. Her menu puts them beside Braised Beef (1896), which cooks at a lower heat, so the potatoes want an oven of their own.

Escalloped Potatoes. Wash, pare, soak, and cut four potatoes in one-fourth inch slices. Put a layer in buttered baking-dish, sprinkle with salt and pepper, dredge with flour, and dot over with one-half tablespoon butter; repeat. Add hot milk until it may be seen through top layer, bake one and one-fourth hours or until potato is soft.

Fannie Merritt FarmerThe Boston Cooking-School Cook Book (Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1896), Escalloped Potatoes, p. 278; dinner menu with Braised Beef, p. 518

Read the full story

Ingredients

For 4 servings. Quantities are shown as written.

Quantities as written here, for 4 servings.

  • Medium potatoes, such as russet or Yukon Gold4Author measures: about 1 1/2 lb.
  • Soft butter, for the dish1 tsp
  • Salt1/2 tsp
  • Ground black pepper1/8 tsp
  • All-purpose flour2 tbsp
  • Butter, in small pieces1 tbsp
  • Milk, heated1 1/2 cups
Ingredients as written here
  • 4 medium potatoes (about 1½ lb), such as russet or Yukon Gold
  • 1 tsp soft butter, for the dish
  • ½ tsp salt
  • ⅛ tsp ground black pepper
  • 2 tbsp all-purpose flour
  • 1 tbsp butter, in small pieces
  • 1½ cups milk, heated
Equipment
  • Vegetable peeler
  • Sharp knife
  • Mixing bowl
  • Small saucepan
  • Baking dish

Instructions

  1. Heat the oven to 350°F (175°C), with a shelf in the middle. Rub the inside of the 1½-quart (1.5-liter) baking dish with the soft butter for the dish.

  2. Wash and peel the potatoes, cut them into slices ¼ inch (6 mm) thick and put them in the mixing bowl. Cover them with cold water and leave them for 15 minutes, then drain them and pat them dry with a clean towel.

  3. Lay half the potato slices in the dish, overlapping. Sprinkle them with half the salt and ground black pepper, dust them with half the flour and dot them with half the butter in small pieces.

  4. Repeat with the rest of the potatoes, salt, pepper, flour and butter.

  5. Heat the milk in the small saucepan until it steams, then pour it down the side of the dish until you can just see it through the top layer of potatoes.

  6. Bake uncovered for about 1¼ hours, until the top is browned in places and a knife slides through the potatoes with no resistance. Let the dish stand for 5 minutes before serving.

Nutrition

235calories per serving

Recipe makes
4 servings
Servings
4

Estimated per serving (4) from USDA FoodData Central values for raw potatoes, whole milk, butter and all-purpose flour.

Recipe notes

When adjusting quantities

Farmer’s own four potatoes in two layers. For more, use a bigger dish and keep to two or three layers, with half a tablespoon of butter and a dusting of flour on each; add hot milk until it shows through the top layer.

Notes

Quantities mentioned in these notes don’t change when you adjust the servings.

Farmer names the four potatoes, the ¼-inch slices, the half tablespoon of butter on each layer and the baking time. The oven setting, the dish size, the soaking time and the amounts of salt, pepper, flour and milk are ours; the oven follows modern scalloped potatoes made the same way, which bake at 350°F (175°C) for about an hour. If the milk bubbles over the rim, set a baking sheet on the shelf below. Chill leftovers within 2 hours and reheat them until hot through. Contains dairy and wheat (flour).

Recipe details

Course
Side dish
Dish family
Vegetables & Sides
Region
American
Era
19th century
Source decade
1890s
Event
Tomb of Yuya and Thuya, 1386–1349 BC
Main ingredient
Vegetables
Difficulty
Easy
Occasion
Everyday meal
Season
Winter
Open in a new tab